Showing posts sorted by relevance for query curt brown. Sort by date Show all posts
Showing posts sorted by relevance for query curt brown. Sort by date Show all posts

Sunday, October 20, 2024

Curt Brown, Paul Bunyan, and Incorrect Memory

I've been a fan of Curt Brown's Minnesota history column in the Sunday Star Tribune for a while (past posts here). I just learned that today was his last column (gift link).

The subject of the column is Paul Bunyan, and more specifically William Laughead, a one-time lumberjack who later went into advertising for lumber companies. He created illustrations of Bunyan and compiled and added to stories he'd heard from his coworkers during his days in the woods. 

As Doug Mack said on BlueSky,

Paul Bunyan, the genial mascot of the North Woods, is lumber company propaganda meant to whitewash settler colonialism and environmental destruction.

Which seems obvious to me now, but when I was growing up in Upstate New York, was invisible to me. I had the confusion that Paul Bunyan had built the Erie Canal and was therefore a New York thing, somehow confusing his ox with Sal, the mule named in the Erie Canal song ("Low Bridge"). It seems as though I was taught in school that the song was about Paul Bunyan, but maybe that's an invented memory.

I have just disabused myself of the notion: The canal song never mentions Paul Bunyan, or even building the canal. It's about a mule-driver who works along the canal. I also assumed the song was older than the Minnesota-era of Bunyan lore, since the canal is from the mid-1800s, but it turns out it's fairly contemporaneous. The song was first recorded in 1912; the earliest printed mentions of Bunyan (Bunion) are from 1893 and 1904.

Thanks to Curt Brown for all of the columns, and making me look up things I never questioned.


Sunday, February 12, 2023

Sarah Wakefield

Score another one for Curt Brown's Minnesota history column in the Sunday Star Tribune.

This week's is about a woman named Sarah Wakefield, a white woman who was held, with her two young children, by the Dakota for six weeks in 1862 during the U.S.-Dakota War.

Out of 100 people who testified afterward, Wakefield was the only one who refused to go along with the pressure to paint the Dakota as abusive to the people they held, even when they were not. Her captor, a man named Chaska, protected her from assault and gave her a blanket even when it meant going without himself.

Chaska was one of the 38 Dakota men hanged in Mankato, Minnesota, on December 26, 1862, despite Wakefield's testimony. Why? He was mistaken for another man of the same name. (Chaska means first-born son.) Authorities later admitted they had killed the wrong man. 

Wakefield published a book in 1864 called Six Weeks in the Sioux Teepees. Brown quotes her criticism of the U.S. government policies that led "a militant faction of starving Dakota to wage war":

Suppose the same number whites were living in sight of food, purchased with their own money, and their children dying of starvation, how long think you would they remain quiet?

It's inspiring to see that a "woman of her time" could see and understand this just as clearly as someone with the benefit of years of hindsight. We have plenty of people in Minnesota today who still don't understand that, and who try to sow dissension about it. 

So I'm grateful to Curt Brown and the people whose research he cites for telling me about Sarah Wakefield, and to the Dakota people who were living their values despite everything white settlers were doing to prevent them.


Sunday, April 18, 2021

Anna Arnold Hedgeman

The Sunday Star Tribune includes a Minnesota History column by writer Curt Brown, which is both almost always worth reading and about someone I have never heard of. Today's subject is Anna Arnold Hedgeman, who grew up in Anoka, a town north of Minneapolis that's now considered a suburb, though it was a separate place before it was absorbed by the metro area. 

Anna Arnold was born in 1899 in Iowa, but moved with her family to Anoka as a child. They were the only Black family in Anoka. Like some of the indomitable early-20th-century Black Minnesota women I've mentioned earlier, she graduated from college here (Hamline University, in her case) before leaving the area because it denied her opportunity. She wanted to be a teacher, but 1922 Saint Paul told her it didn't hire Negroes.

It was Minnesota's loss. She left to work at an HBCU in the south, then worked for the YWCA in several states over the next 20 or so years. She worked on fair employment in the 1940s, for the mayor of New York in the 1950s, and ran for city council and Congress there. 

She was the only woman on the decidedly sexist planning committee for the March on Washington in 1963, and according to Brown's article, was responsible for bringing together Martin Luther King Jr.'s planned July march and A. Philip Randolph's planned October march into the single march we now know in August for Jobs and Freedom (with a side of Bayard Rustin organizing). She was also responsible, Brown says, for getting the only woman who spoke that day onto the speakers' list.

She wrote two books along the way, published in 1965 and 1977.

Anna Arnold Hedgeman lived to be 90 years old. She died in 1990 in New York City. What a life.


Thursday, August 16, 2012

The Anniversary of the Dakota War

The largest mass public execution in U.S. history was carried out in Minnesota 150 years ago. 38 Dakota men were hung in Mankato after the so-called Dakota War.


Minnesota was shaped by that war and the executions; the names of the white military and civilian leaders surrounds us--on our counties, towns, schools, and buildings--every day. The story of the war was told by the victors, of course, but with each major anniversary, a little more of the story has come out.

With this sesquicentennial, a lot more has been written and shown. The Minnesota History Center mounted an exhibit called The U.S.-Dakota War of 1862, and this past week the Star Tribune's Curt Brown published a six-part series called In the Footsteps of Little Crow. I recommend the series strongly -- as well as the op-ed from today's paper offering more information about Sarah Wakefield, who was caught up in the conflict.

There are many facts in the stories that I never knew, but some that stand out from today's story:

  • 303 men were sentenced to be hanged. After an Episcopal bishop interceded with Abraham Lincoln, 265 of them were reprieved from hanging because they had participated in battle but not in killing civilians. What I didn't know was that 120 of those reprieved men died the next winter in a military barracks in Davenport, Iowa. 
  • Hundreds of noncombatant Dakota (including women and children) died in a detention camp at Fort Snelling near what are now the Twin Cities. The next year, they were shipped down the Mississippi, up the Missouri, and then sent in boxcars to the Crow Creek reservation in South Dakota. Curtis wrote, "Many starved that first winter. Some survived by plucking grain from the dung of livestock."
  • William Mayo, who went on to found the Mayo Clinic, was working in a field hospital during the war. After the mass execution in Mankato, the bodies were buried "only to be dug up that night by doctors who drew lots to get the cadavers for anatomy research. Dr. William Mayo claimed the body of a man known as Cut Nose to use teaching his son Will and Charlie before they formed their famous clinic."
The war is still contentious in Minnesota, as evidenced by a series of letters that appeared in the Strib before Brown's articles appeared. But Brown's stories and the History Center's exhibit both provide a lot of substance and subtlety to an event that is much too easily oversimplified.

Sunday, July 28, 2019

Mary Colter

One of the joys of my local newspaper the Star Tribune is the history column by Curt Brown that runs on Sundays. I've mentioned his work twice before (here and here).

Today he wrote about Mary Colter, 1869–1958, who was the architect of multiple buildings in the Grand Canyon National Park. She moved to Saint Paul with her family at age 11, went to school here, taught in the public schools for 15 years, and, after leaving for her long life and career, was buried in Oakland Cemetery just north of downtown.

In Brown's words, 
In 1922, they were going to name the new lodging [in the Grand Canyon] after National Park champion and 26th President Theodore Roosevelt. Then the project’s pioneering female architect from St. Paul spoke up.

“A woman ahead of her time, Mary Colter had other ideas,” according to a Grand Canyon pamphlet. “The company’s architect, with her characteristic independence, preferred the more romantic, mysterious-sounding ‘Phantom Ranch.’ ”
Later in the article, Brown writes:
Her Grand Canyon structures and Southwestern hotel designs eschewed the American architectural trends of the time that...“superimposed” Europe’s classical Roman columns “on the American landscape.... Mary Colter was more interested in rediscovering the cultural heritage of the region than in imitating European styles” [quotes from Virginia Grattan in her 1980 book, Mary Colter: Builder Upon Red Earth].

She often trekked to remote corners of the Southwest to study Indian ruins and artifacts.
Here are the Grand Canyon buildings Colter designed:


Hopi House, 1905


Hermit's Rest, 1914 (I think this is the only one of Colter's buildings I've seen in person).


Phantom Ranch, 1922. According to Colter's Wikipedia entry, the design of this building "became a de facto model for subsequent National Park Service and Civilian Conservation Corps structures, influencing the look and feel of an entire genre of parkitecture, often called National Park Service Rustic. Her structures at the Grand Canyon set the precedent for using on-site materials and bold, large-scale design elements."


Watchtower, 1932


Bright Angel Lodge, 1935

2019 is the 100th anniversary of the Grand Canyon as a National Park and the 150th birthday of Mary Colter.

Sunday, September 25, 2022

A Lesson from 1890

I've mentioned Curt Brown's Minnesota history column before, which runs in the Sunday Star Tribune.

Today's subject was a woman named Mary Weishar, who murdered her husband Frank in 1880 in the southern part of the state. She was convicted and served about nine years, though it sounds like he was a terrible person (at least he was a former mercenary soldier and a "notorious thief," and I am imagining reasons from their home life why she may have felt a need to do it).

But even so, I wouldn't be writing about the column except for one thing: The oldest child of Mary and Frank Weishar, also named Frank, was 10 years old when his father died and his mother went to prison. Despite that, as an adult

[he] became a leading citizen.

He founded the Todd County Tribune, farmed successfully, sired 13 kids, became active in Nonpartisan League politics, served the township and school board, and was an officer at the local creamery. When he died at 60 in 1930, 600 people attended his funeral.

That made me think about how people sometimes think biology is destiny. In this case, that would mean a kid whose father was a mercenary and a thief and whose mother was a murderer would necessarily turn out badly no matter what.

But despite the trauma that young Frank must have lived through, and his implied genes, he became a more exemplary person than many others. Who knows what happened in his life experience as a young person that may have helped him?

Human genetics are not simplistically determined, and when you include the spectrum of environmental variables and human interactions possible, the range of outcomes broadens further.

I know that many people would have written the child Frank off as a lost cause back in 1890, just as they write off all sorts of children today. He stands out as a case of how wrong that kind of thinking can be.
__

Brown's column about Mary Weishar and her son Frank is based on research carried out at the Minnesota History Center by Bruce Taber, their descendant.


Monday, February 25, 2019

Harriet Scott

I've said before: white people know nothing about black people and their history in this country, and here's another example.

I may have learned something about the horrible Dred Scott decision in high school, but it must have been one factoid among many. Somewhere along the way I found out about it, though. Maybe from Howard Zinn's A People's History of the United States. Or maybe I had heard that the case was based on Scott's having lived in Minnesota. By whatever means, though, I knew enough about it to have an interest in seeing the courtroom where the case was heard when I visited St. Louis in the early 1990s.

But here's an aspect of the case I've never heard before, which was written up in Curt Brown's Star Tribune history column on Sunday: It wasn't just Dred Scott who sued for his freedom, it was also his wife Harriet. And that she may have been more insistent on the legal case than even he was because their children were reaching an age when their enslavers were more likely to sell them.

There isn't a lot of information about Harriet online. I hope I remember to look for more about her instead of forgetting again.